Subject: How to graph an expression involving sum?
From: dlakelan
Date: Fri, 09 Sep 2011 12:28:28 -0700
On 09/08/2011 09:09 PM, Mario Rodriguez wrote:
> On 09/05/2011 04:08 PM, dlakelan wrote:
>> I have a solution of a differential equation in terms of some fourier
>> series. I would like to graph one of the spatially varying coefficients,
>> so I tried something like:
>>
>> draw2d(explicit(subst(avals,coefseries),z,0,1));
>>
>> Where coefseries is something like a[0] + sum(a[i]*cos(...),i,1,17) and
>> avals are the values for a[0]...a[17] in a list of the form
>> [a[0]=...,a[1]=..., ...]
>>
>> but what the subst gives me is still in the form 1.234 +
>> sum(a[i]*cos(...)...), that is, subst substituted the constant
>> coefficient but of course not the individual coefficients in the sum
>> (since they only appear as a[i]).
> This is what I get:
>
>
> (%i12) display2d:false$
>
> (%i13) avals: makelist(a[i]=random(10)-5,i,0,17);
>
> (%o13) [a[0] = -2,a[1] = -2,a[2] = 2,a[3] = 3,a[4] = -1,a[5] = 1,a[6] = 0,
> a[7] = -5,a[8] = 2,a[9] = 1,a[10] = 0,a[11] = -1,a[12] = 2,a[13]
> = -3,
> a[14] = 3,a[15] = -2,a[16] = -5,a[17] = 1]
> (%i14) coefseries: a[0] + sum(a[i]*cos(z*i*%pi),i,1,17);
>
> (%o14) a[17]*cos(17*%pi*z)+a[16]*cos(16*%pi*z)+a[15]*cos(15*%pi*z)
> +a[14]*cos(14*%pi*z)+a[13]*cos(13*%pi*z)
> +a[12]*cos(12*%pi*z)+a[11]*cos(11*%pi*z)
> +a[10]*cos(10*%pi*z)+a[9]*cos(9*%pi*z)
> +a[8]*cos(8*%pi*z)+a[7]*cos(7*%pi*z)
> +a[6]*cos(6*%pi*z)+a[5]*cos(5*%pi*z)
> +a[4]*cos(4*%pi*z)+a[3]*cos(3*%pi*z)
> +a[2]*cos(2*%pi*z)+a[1]*cos(%pi*z)+a[0]
>
> Don't you get this expanded expression? Perhaps I misunderstood your
> problem.
coefseries variable contains the noun form of the sum, I seem to have
quoted it when I created it so that it wouldn't expand. If I force it to
evaluate with the flag "nouns" i can get it expanded. Is that the right
way to go about it, or is there a way where I don't have to expand the
expression but can still get numerical evaluation? in other words, where
maxima will calculate the numerical sum without constructing and
carrying around a potentially long symbolic expression?